Are Gutters Included in Roof Replacement? Everything Homeowners Need to Know

TLDR;

Gutters are not always included in a standard roof replacement, but they can be if needed and requested. Whether they’re removed, replaced, or left alone depends on their condition, your roofing contractor’s practices, and the scope of the job.

What’s Actually Included in a Roof Replacement?

When you hire a roofing contractor for a roof replacement, you're not just getting new shingles.

Most full roof replacements include:

• Tear-off of old shingles
  
• Inspection and replacement of damaged decking
  
• Installation of underlayment
  
• New shingles or roofing material
  
• Drip edge and flashing
  
• Ventilation systems
  
• Final inspection and cleanup
  
  

But here's the key point: gutters are not automatically included unless specified in your contract. Some companies, like The Amish Roofer, may offer gutter work as an add-on, but it’s not standard across the board.

The Importance of Gutters in Your Roofing System

Gutters do more than just direct rainwater away from your house—they protect your roof, siding, foundation, and even landscaping.

Here’s how they contribute:

• Manage rainwater runoff to prevent erosion and basement flooding
  
• Protect fascia boards and soffits from rot
  
• Prevent water backup under shingles
  
• Extend the lifespan of your roof and home exterior

Learn more about How Gutters Impact Roofs and why maintaining a strong gutter system is critical to your home's overall health.

If your gutters are clogged, sagging, or leaking, they can compromise the integrity of your new roof—which is why gutter condition should be evaluated during any roof replacement project.

Are Gutters Replaced with the Roof?

Short answer: Not always—but they can be.

Here’s when gutters might be part of the job:

• If they’re damaged or rusted
  
• If their layout interferes with roofing installation
  
• If your contractor offers bundled services
  
• If you request it as part of the quote
  
  

Here’s when they’re usually not replaced:

• If gutters are in good shape and properly installed
  
• If the roof installation doesn't affect the gutters
  
• If the homeowner is trying to limit budget
  
  

At The Amish Roofer, we always assess gutter condition as part of our roof inspection. We’ll recommend replacement only if it’s practical and necessary—not just to pad the bill.

Signs It’s Time to Replace Your Gutters

Not sure if your gutters need to go with your old roof? Watch for these red flags:

• Visible sagging or separation from the roofline
  
• Rust spots or holes
  
• Frequent clogging despite cleaning
  
• Watermarks on siding or signs of fascia rot
  
• Pooling water near your home’s foundation
  
  

Replacing a roof without addressing failing gutters is like putting on a new coat over a soaked shirt—it won’t last.

Should I Replace Gutters and Roof at the Same Time?

There are definite advantages to combining both jobs:

Pros:

• Saves time and labor costs since one crew can handle both
  
• Ensures complete integration between the gutter system and new roof
  
• Eliminates future disruption to your home’s exterior
  
• Helps maintain aesthetics and curb appeal
  
  

Cons:

• Higher upfront cost
  
• Some gutter systems may still have usable life left
  
  

If your gutters are more than 15–20 years old, it's usually smart to replace them alongside the roof. At The Amish Roofer, we often recommend this approach when it makes long-term financial sense.

Cost to Replace Roof and Gutters Together

Understanding the cost breakdown helps you budget smarter.

Average Roof Replacement:

• $8,000 to $15,000 depending on material, home size, and pitch
  
  

Average Gutter Replacement:

• $5 to $30 per linear foot depending on material:
  
  
• Vinyl: $5–$8/ft
  
• Aluminum: $6–$12/ft
  
• Steel: $9–$20/ft
  
• Copper: $25–$30+/ft
  
  

Additional Costs:

• Disposal fees
  
• Permit costs
  
• Labor bundling fees or discounts
  
  

Combining both jobs may save 10–15% on labor when done together rather than separately.

Best Gutter Materials for a New Roof

The material of your new gutters should complement the roofing material.

Common Gutter Materials:

• Aluminum – lightweight, rust-resistant, affordable
  
• Vinyl – budget-friendly, easy to install, but less durable
  
• Steel – strong, handles heavy loads, but prone to rust
  
• Copper – premium look, long lifespan, higher cost
  
  

Compatibility Considerations:

• Asphalt Shingles pair well with aluminum or vinyl
  
• Metal Roofs work best with steel or copper
  
• Tile Roofs often require custom-designed gutters due to weight
  
  

Always match gutter durability and aesthetics to the roof you’re investing in.

Regional Factors That Influence Gutter Decisions

Climate plays a huge role in your gutter and roof choices.

In Rainy or Snowy Regions:

• Larger gutters (6") handle runoff better
  
• Heated gutters can reduce ice dams
  
• Steeper roof pitches require better drainage
  
  

In Hot and Dry Climates:

• UV-resistant materials are essential
  
• Less frequent but intense rainstorms demand effective flow management
  
  

Also, local building codes may require certain materials or downspout configurations. That’s why at The Amish Roofer, we always review local regulations before making recommendations.

What Roofing Contractors Say About Gutters

Every contractor has their own policy. Here’s what you should ask:

• Is gutter removal and reattachment included in your quote?
  
• Will you inspect and recommend gutter upgrades?
  
• Can you handle both roof and gutter replacement?
  
  

At The Amish Roofer, we believe in transparency. If your gutters need work, we tell you. If they’re in good shape, we won’t upsell you.

Debunking Common Myths About Roof and Gutter Replacement

Myth #1: New roof means new gutters

Not true. Unless your gutters are failing, you don’t have to replace them—but it may still be smart.

Myth #2: I’ll wait on gutters

Delaying gutter replacement can allow water damage to sneak in behind your new roof system.

Myth #3: DIY is just as good



Improperly reattached gutters can void your new roof’s warranty. Always hire a pro.

FAQs About Roof and Gutter Replacement

Do I need to remove gutters before replacing a roof?

Not always. Some roofers can work around them or temporarily detach and reattach if needed.

Will roofers remove gutters?

Only if necessary or specified. Always clarify in your quote.

Should I replace gutters before or after a roof?

Ideally, during the same project—especially if your gutters are aging or failing.

Making the Final Call on Roof and Gutter Replacement

So—should you replace your gutters during a roof replacement? It depends on:

• Condition of your current gutter system
  
• Age of your home and exterior features
  
• Your budget and long-term plans
  
• Contractor capabilities
  
  

At The Amish Roofer, we help homeowners make confident, informed decisions. Our roofing experts will evaluate your entire water management system, not just your shingles. That way, your investment is protected for years to come.

If your roof is ready for replacement, and your gutters are showing signs of age, don’t wait. Bundle the projects. Save time, money, and stress down the road.